8 out of 10 PMSes Out-Performed Nifty in November

The Indian stock benchmark Nifty 50 fell 3.9% in November, but the declines in the broader market were gentler. Midcaps fell 2.7% while smallcaps were largely flat. Naturally, PMS strategies that usually spread their bets across the market performed better. As many as 219 PMSes out-performed the Nifty 50 in November, i.e. almost 83% of the PMS strategies tracked by PMS Bazaar. Due to the lop-sided nature of market performance this month, the best performing PMS strategies belonged to midcap, small & midcap, multicap, smallcap buckets. Here is a recap.

13 Dec 2021
8 out of 10 PMSes Out-Performed Nifty in November

Best strategies of the month

Headlines of a quicker than expected Fed tapering & new Covid-19 variant set off nervousness in stock markets in November. And with markets trading near all-time highs, both in terms of levels and historical valuations, a mild sell-off ensued.

Given that it was a negative month for equities, the top-10 performers totally bucked the trend and delivered reasonable positive gains to investors. Leading the pack was Right Horizons Super Value strategy. This is midcap scheme with almost a 3 year vintage. The PMS gained 4.58% in November, a handsome 700 basis point alpha over Nifty Midcap 100 (down 2.69%). Number 2 this month was Silverarch Mid & Small Cap Equity with 3.7% gain, followed by Systematix Dynamic Investment Portfolio at no. 3 with its multicap theme generating 3.35%.

After the top 3 PMS strategies were SageOne Small & Microcap (up 2.75%), Composite Investments Emerging Star Fund (up 2.65%), Carnelian Shift Strategy (up 2.18%), Green Portfolio Dividend Yield (up 1.91%), Centrum Good to Great (up 1.68%), Silverarch India Equity Portfolio (up 1.68%) and Wize Market Analytics Capital Mind - Long Term Portfolio (up 1.48%).

Given that the mood on the stock market was negative the top 10 in November 2021 were not the usual ones seen in October or September. The best performers had some exposure to Health Care, IT & Power sectors that stood out in November giving positive returns in an otherwise declining market.

Best PMS categories

Largecap - The average category return of largecap PMSes in November was -2.88%, with about 14 of 21 strategies under-performing this number against Nifty 50's 3.9% loss. The top performers from largecap PMS space were Agreya Capital Advisors Exposure Equity Index Strategy (down 0.08%), Wize Market Analytics Capital Mind - Market Fund (down 0.66%) and Ambit Inv. Advisors Coffee Can (down 1.39%).

Large & midcap - About half a dozen strategies in this segment reported a category average of -1.94% in November. The better performers among them wer Upside AI 250 (up 1.37%), Sykes & Rays Equities SRE Shield (-0.16%) and Bonanza Growth (-1.87%).

Midcap - The 21 midcap PMS strategies recorded a category average return of -1.37% in November, out-performing the Nifty Midcap 100 index's 2.69% decline. The 3 top best performers this month from midcap PMSes are Right Horizons Super Value (up 4.58%), Centrum Good to Great (up 1.68%) and Centrum Deep Value (up 1.44%).

Small & midcap - This category has 20 strategies that are tracked by PMS Bazaar. The category average in Nov-21 was -1.5%. This month's top 3 performers are Silverarch Mid & Small Cap Equity (up 3.7%), Composite Investments Emerging Star (up 2.65%) and Edelweiss Focused Smallcap (up 0.91%).

Smallcap - The 15 strategies tracked by PMS Bazaar in the smallcap PMS space reported a category average of -1.74% in November 2021. This fares poorly against BSE Smallcap that fell barely -0.16% in the same month. Nevertheless, the top 3 performers are SageOne Small & Microcap (up 2.75%), AccuraCap Picopower (up 1.43%) and Equitree Capital Advisors Emerging Opportunities (up 1.24%).

Multicap - This is the biggest category of equity PMS schemes. The category average of the 153 schemes was -2.15%, which is better than BSE 500's return of -2.97% in Nov-2021. The top 3 performers of multicap PMSes this month were Systematix Dynamic Investment Portfolio (up 3.35%), Carnelian Shift Strategy (up 2.18%) and Silverarch India Equity Portfolio (up 1.68%).

Thematic & sector - There are 12 thematic and sector PMSes tracked by PMS Bazaar. Green Portfolio Dividend Yield and Super 30 with 1.91% and 0.42% gain respectively topped the charts in November 2021.

Recent Blogs

Emergence of a robust new asset class of high yield credit investment opportunities

Real estate means different things to different people. For the average joe, it is home. For a builder, it is raw material. For users, it can be office, property, warehouse, hotels and what not. From an investing perspective, Real Estate or RE makes imminent sense for Indian HNIs, family offices, NRIs and offshore capital pools. Real Estate asset backed investments bring something very refreshing to the table for investors. In fact, RE backed investing is emerging as a robust new asset class when you combine them with High Yield (HY) credit investment opportunities.

Every 2nd PMS strategy beats Nifty's 6.6 per cent jump in February

Small-Cap, Mid-Cap Strategies outshine Large-Caps and broader markets

Why Multi Asset Strategy Is The Best Way To Navigate Markets

Investing legend Warren Buffett has always warned against putting all your eggs in one basket. But, thousands and lakhs of investors over the years have repeated this terrible mistake. What happens when all your eggs are in one basket? Returns become one big financial omelette!

PMSes with falling cash holdings outnumber those who maintained or raised moolah

There are 8 PMSes who have zero cash in their portfolios at the end of June; only 1 strategy now holds more than 50% cash compared to 2 in May

140 PMSes beat Nifty's 2.84% gain in September

More than half of the PMS schemes, led by midcap strategies, out-perform the benchmark

Soonicorns, Unicorns and Listings: The Transformation of India's Public Equity Markets

The stories of Flipkart, Paytm, Nykaa and other start-ups that define India are well-known. In a small but significant way, these unicorns also represent the dreams and aspirations of a new breed of corporates since they have been built by first-generation entrepreneurs. They developed business models that would not only meet unmet needs of the masses, but also attracted huge bets from investing capital from around the world. As we have seen, many of these homegrown start-ups are going for public listings aka IPOs and thereby creating history again in the public equity market. To talk about this very interesting opportunity, PMS Bazaar recently hosted Avendus and its top leadership in a webinar titled 'The Coming Transformation of India's Public Equity Markets'. The speakers were Ranu Vohra, co-founder and executive vice chairman, Avendus Capital and Tridib Pathak, co-head of equity, Ocean Dial Asset Management India and fund manager, Avendus Olivo (PMS strategy). The insightful session was anchored by Sivaram.

IIFL’s Multicap PMS consistent out-performance backed by their cautiously-optimistic approach

It is quite inspiring to hear out the convictions of the out performers during the current uncertainties. Mr. Mitul Patel’s cautiously optimistic approach is evidenced by consistent out performance of IIFL PMS strategies. Read on to get inspired by the optimism of Mr. Mitul Patel.

"To win the investing game, understand the field"

In a special session organized by PMS Bazaar, two experts from Helios namely storied fund manager Samir Arora, and Dinshaw Irani, the CIO of Helios India, shared with investors their lessons and experiences over an hour-long interaction. The investing gurus asked investors to be flexible and challenge the common myths that float around. Samir is a very well-known and respected market voice. He shared his views on some of the assertions any investor would probably hear, and then tried to reveal the reality behind such assertions. Dinshaw explained the investing philosophy behind the Helios India Rising PMS. Read on to know more details.